Cities Similar to Carthage, IL
The top 10 most similar cities based on cost of living, home prices, rent, population, and region.
Cities similar to Carthage, IL
1. Casey, IL
2,350 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$119K
Rent estimate
$740/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →2. Harrison, MI
2,162 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$120K
Rent estimate
$740/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →3. Dunkirk, IN
2,098 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$121K
Rent estimate
$750/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →4. Phillipsburg, KS
2,244 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$115K
Rent estimate
$730/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →5. Hamilton, IL
2,689 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$116K
Rent estimate
$860/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →6. Villa Grove, IL
2,440 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$127K
Rent estimate
$850/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →7. Henry, IL
2,312 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$112K
Rent estimate
$720/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →8. Piedmont, MO
1,861 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$119K
Rent estimate
$800/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →9. Norton, KS
2,676 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$118K
Rent estimate
$700/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →10. Galva, IL
2,414 people · Midwest
COL Index
Not available
Home value
$106K
Rent estimate
$800/mo
Compared: home value, rent estimate, population, region. Partial data: missing factors reduce the score.
Compare →How We Find Cities Similar to Carthage
We compare saved cost indexes (30% of the score), home values (20%), rent estimates (15%), population (15%) and region (20%). Financial differences are measured relative to the two cities, and population uses a logarithmic scale. Rent estimates prefer city ZIP data when available.
A match needs at least two financial factors available for both cities. Missing factors reduce the score instead of counting as matches. Each card lists the factors actually compared. Scores are a ranking aid, not a percentage probability, a measure of data accuracy, or a promise of a similar lifestyle. Climate, schools, jobs and your personal budget are not part of this score.
Click on any city in the results to see a detailed cost of living comparison, including category-by-category breakdowns for housing, groceries, transportation, healthcare, and more. You can also adjust the search to find cities similar to any location in the United States.